Sustainable Packaging: Recyclable vs. Biodegradable

Companies in the frozen food, pet food, and towel and tissue industries who haven’t yet “gone green” are lagging behind their more forward-thinking competitors in the area of sustainable packaging. With multiple options for more sustainable packaging—including recyclable and biodegradable packaging—how can you be certain which is better for your product, your consumers, and the environment?

Tree inside a crystal ball on a wooden stump

Sustainable Packaging Option: Recyclable Packaging

Technically speaking, all packaging is recyclable, however, the recyclability of a given package is entirely dependent on whether or not a resell market exists for the materials that are left when the product reaches end-of-life. Such a market does exist for many materials that packaging tends to be made out of. The main complicating factor is that most packaging is made out of two or more materials, and it’s often too difficult or expensive to separate those materials to recycle them (consider the ease of separating the plastic and paper that make up a cereal box vs. the laminated layers of a flexible package).

The champion of the sustainable packaging movement, however, is still the recyclable package. Recyclable packaging is easy for consumers to understand, recycling facilities are becoming more commonplace everywhere from urban centres to rural communities, and it requires the least energy expenditure—when other sustainable packaging options reach end-of-life and cannot be reused, net new materials must be created to replace them.

Still, the materials separation problem persists—if flexible packaging materials can’t be easily separated, they can’t be easily recycled. On the other hand, if the packaging materials can be easily separated, it’s often an indicator of a flexible package with poor ink protection and barrier control.

To combat this problem—quality vs. sustainability of a flexible package—we developed SmartPack™, which uses energy-curing technology to reduce the number of films needed to produce a sustainable flexible package with a proprietary coating. This VOC-free process gives packaging the premium look and performance that used to only be possible with a multi-film composition, but the result is a completely recyclable package.

Sustainable Packaging Option: Biodegradable Packaging

“Biodegradable” simply refers to any material that can be broken down into its smallest possible components by living micro-organisms without causing harm. Lots of materials are technically biodegradable but, if the degradation process takes dozens or even hundreds of years, it doesn’t do much good for the environment.

To meet the definition of sustainable packaging, biodegradable materials used in packaging must break down in a reasonable amount of time. Biodegradable is not the same as compostable (see the next section of this post for more on compostable packaging).

As sustainable packaging options, our SmartPack-BDG™ and PetPack-BDG™ give both producers and consumers the premium product they want without leaving waste behind. They’re the easiest sustainable packages to dispose of—you can simply throw them in your regular garbage, and they will begin to degrade in an active landfill (anaerobic) environment. Plus, SmartPack-BDG™ is also fully recyclable, giving consumers added flexibility when their package reaches end of life.

Both SmartPack-BDG™ and PetPack-BDG™ have been tested and validated against ASTM D5511, so users can rest assured that complete biodegradation occurs in a sustainable amount of time and leaves behind zero toxic residue.

Sustainable Packaging (Bonus) Option: Compostable Packaging

Compostable packaging may be the ultimate solution to the sustainable packaging problem. Like biodegradable packaging, compostable packaging breaks down into individual components: water, CO2, biomass, and inorganic compounds. Composting leaves behind no visible residue.

There are two reasons compostable packaging isn’t more commonplace today: first, not all municipalities offer composting facilities (although many are catching up), and second, compostable films tend to be more costly than other sustainable packaging options. As technology improves, composting facilities expand, and more consumers demand sustainable packaging options, the cost of compostable film will decrease as it did (and continues to do) for recyclable films.

Our R&D department has developed compostable films that still offer premium performance and product protection—click here to talk to Project Central about our innovative compostable packaging technology.

Sustainable Packaging & Your Product

The answer to “which sustainable packaging option is best?” is wholly dependent on how it will be used, who will be using it, and where your consumer market is located.

Many producers choose recyclable packaging as their sustainable packaging option of choice because it’s easy to understand, relatively inexpensive to produce, and consumes less energy throughout its lifecycle than other options.

However, as consumer understanding of sustainable packaging options evolves and facilities to handle compostable and other forms of biodegradable packaging become more widespread, we may see a shift in this trend in the near future.

Whatever your plan for increased package sustainability in the future, it’s important to your consumers that sustainability be prioritized throughout the entire supply chain.

Since the year 2000, per foot shipped, Emmerson Packaging has…

  • Reduced residual solid waste by 87%
  • Lowered water usage more than 78%
  • Reduced electricity usage by 41%
  • Reduced VOC emissions by over 55%
  • Became a certified SGP Printer.

…all while developing new and innovative sustainable packaging options like SmartPack™, SmartPack-BDG™, and PetPack-BDG™.

Read more about all of Emmerson Packaging’s green and sustainable options, and to begin on your organization’s own path to sustainability, click here to start a conversation with Emmerson Packaging’s Project Central about a customized sustainable packaging solution for your product.

Talk to Project Central


You are using an outdated browser. Things may not appear as intended. We recommend updating your browser to the latest version.